HOMEABOUT USBULLETIN BOARDCALENDARNEIGHBORHOODSHOMES FOR SALEELECTIONSVOLUNTEERENTERTAINMENTPARKSANIMALSSCHOOLSNEWSPAPERSSAFETYGOVERNMENT"TRASH" TALKLINKSARCHIVESGAS DRILLING

 

THIS WEBPAGE BEST VIEWED AT 1680 X 1050 RESOLUTION
meadowbrooktoday/DowntownViewIMG0001.jpg

THE CARTER AVENUE PIPELINE STORY 


 

CLICK HERE FOR THE VIDEO

Carter Avenue runs along a large limestone outcropping known as Sycamore Heights.  Sycamore Creek flows down below and the western ridge offers sweeping views of downtown Fort Worth and amazing sunsets.


 

Bordered by huge greenspaces - Tandy Hills Natural Area to the east and Gateway Park to the north - Sycamore Heights retains a unique country ambience for such close-in urban location. 

meadowbrooktoday/TandyHillAutumn.JPG
Tandy Hills Natural Area ( Photo by Don Young)
 
 

This idyllic setting is complicated by Lancaster Avenue to the south.

 

meadowbrooktoday/Homeless.jpg

A concentration of homeless shelters continue to present a serious challenge to the Sycamore Heights neighborhood.  Crime-infested motels and a plasma center that pays cash for blood do not help the situation.

 
 

After decades of neglect,  Sycamore Heights and Carter Avenue finally seemed to be on the verge of a turnaround in the year 2008. The freshly paved streets were lined with brand new sidewalks and grassy medians. 

meadowbrooktoday/CarterLongViewIMG0001.jpg


 

The residents, a diverse mix of senior citizens, young families with children, singles, immigrants, gays and military families, began remodeling and landscaping their homes.  Carter Avenue became an example of the quality affordable low-income housing that the City of Fort Worth says it so desperately needs.

meadowbrooktoday/WaterWellIMG0001.jpg
meadowbrooktoday/RoundBushesIMG0001.jpg
meadowbrooktoday/BungalowIMG0001.jpg



 

meadowbrooktoday/Juanita.jpg

In June of 2008, Carter Avenue residents learned that Texas Midstream Gas Services (a subsidiary of Chesapeake Energy) needed to connect two wells with a gas gathering pipeline.

TMGS decided that the best place for this pipeline would be under Carter Avenue front yards. 


 

The City of Fort Worth and Chesapeake hosted a  community meeting at the Sycamore Community Center on July 14, 2008.  Residents got their first look at the intended route of the pipeline.

meadowbrooktoday/CarterScottGasWell001.jpg



meadowbrooktoday/GasProtest.jpg

Many residents in Sycamore Heights and throughout the whole Meadowbrook area were stunned, then upset and fearful about what they learned at that meeting.  They asked Chesapeake why this pipeline couldn't be run along I-30 instead of through their neighborhood.

 

 

On 7-30-08, West Meadowbrook Neighborhood Association responded to community concerns and hosted a special meeting.  Chesapeake personnel presented their case and many residents and other concerned citizens passionately objected to this pipeline. 

meadowbrooktoday/gymnasium.jpg

 

 

meadowbrooktoday/hicksandveasy.jpg
REP MARC VEASY AND COUNCIL MEMBER KATHLEEN HICKS

 Council Council Member Kathleen Hicks and TX State Representatives Marc Veasy and Lon Burnam listened as residents from across the city expressed their strong concerns about a pipeline below their homes running highly pressurized unprocessed gas that can't be smelled.  A former pipeline executive explained how this type of "wet" gas coming straight off a wellhead can condense and cause pipe failure in just a three years. 

Over and over, residents questioned the wisdom of running this type of gasline through our neighborhoods.  They wanted answers about property values and home insurance coverage. A retired chemist explained the dangers of chemical exposure. 

meadowbrooktoday/jerryhorton.jpg
meadowbrooktoday/suzette2.jpg
meadowbrooktoday/billfisher.jpg
     

In September, 2008, Texas midstream submitted a City permit application to cross Beach Street.

Before even receiving approval for this permit, TMGS began obtaining 20' easements through the front yards on the south side of Carter Avenue.  The south side of the street contains only residences.   The north side of Carter Avenue includes a commercial parking lot for Chase Bank.

Faced with the prospect of eminent domain, some residents signed easement agreements.  Those who would not sign eventually faced a row full of Chesapeake lawyers in eminent domain court.  Most of their easements were seized with very little financial remuneration. Jerry Horton fought to the bitter end:     CHANNEL 11 TALKS WITH JERRY HORTON

As of March 2009, all residential easements had been obtained except those lots owned by the City of Fort Worth...and yet the City Council still had not voted on the permit to cross Beach Street!

Citizens continued to demand an alternate pipeline route.  For months t
he City said they were seeking alternatives routes.  When asked who in the City was working on this, it was explained that the City was looking to Chesapeake for these alternatives.  However, Chesapeake said they were not researching alternative routes. They had determined what they considered the best route and were satisfied with it.

A
fter a public information request was filed, the City released pages of documentation - many duplicate emails and irrelevant information. R
esidents began to wonder about the the City's committment to "seek alternatives".

O
n March 19th, a group of concerned citizens travelled to Austin and testified before the House Committee on Energy Resources - exposing the ugly facts about the Carter Avenue pipeline to a much larger audience.

   
 

Miraculously (and shortly after this hearing)  Chesapeake appeared to have a change of heart ...

O
n 3-27-09 (and coincidentally just before the upcoming citywide Mayoral and City Council elections)  Carter Avenue residents opened their mailboxes to find a letter stating that TMGS was having to "reevaluate" the Thomas to Hickman pipeline due to revisions in the gas ordinance:

meadowbrooktoday/TMGSletter001.jpg

Even though the revised gas ordinance did not require pipeline "reevaluation",  residents were encouraged by Chesapeake's apparent decision to back away from the Carter Avenue pipeline route.  However, some  were concerned that this might just another stall tactic to get through the upcoming City elections. Their concerns were later justified ....

As the Texas legislative session drew to a close in May 2009, TX State Senator Wendy Davis and TX State Rep Lon Burnam struggled to address the problem of industrial gas pipelines in neighborhoods like Carter Avenue.  Even though Davis' S.B.686 was eventually vetoed by Gov Rick Perry, he did sign H.B.2572 which allows gas gathering pipelines to run ALONG public right-of-ways, with some considerations.

After months of silence,  Chesapeake hastily called a "community" meeting at Texas Wesleyan on Oct 15, 2009 that was closed to anyone other than those directly in the pipeline path.  Chesapeake claims they mailed out notices to all affected residents but only two Carter Ave residences reported receiving notices - both of which had incorrect occupant names. When area residents learned of this meeting just a few days before the Oct 15th, they protested to Chesapeake.  On Oct 12th, Chesapeake hastily cancelled and then rescheduled the meeting.  

Less than a handful of residents showed up to hear the Cheseapeake presentation on why Carter Avenue was the only viable route for the Thomas 1H to Hickman pipeline.  Many more Carter residents, offended by Chesapeake's obvious subterfuge,  attended a block party that was held that same afternoon. Amidst hotdogs and balloons, they reconnected and planned strategy to continue this pipeline fight. Click on the following link for more TV coverage:

CHANNEL 33 NEWS REPORT

CarterAveBlockParty/IMG_4430.JPG

Council Rep Kathleen Hicks agreed that the Oct 15th Chesapeake meeting did not qualify as a community meeting.  A few days later, the City, TXDOT, Chesapeake, TX Senator Wenday Davis, and TX Rep Lon Burnam met together and it was revealed that Chesapeake never even applied for a permit to run along I-30. (see Star-Telegram article dated 10-23-9) The City put the street permit vote on hold until they were convinced that Chesapeake fully explored that northern route.

It now appears that good progress has been made on the northern route.  A community meeting will be held December 2, 2009 at Meadowbrook Elementary, 4330 Meadowbrook Drive (see Home Page for details).  Hicks, Burnam and Davis will be in attendance as City staff make their presentation and have a question and answer session.  Let's keep our fingers crossed and hope that this pipeline will be kept out of our neighborhood.

There is no way this type of dangerous pipeline should be allowed to run through ANY neighborhood in ANY part of Fort Worth.  Lack of leadership on the City's part should not condemn Sycamore Heights to future decline and deterioration.

As community awareness increases, support is growing for protecting our neighborhoods from gas-gathering pipelines.  Click on the links below for public statements:

FORT WORTH STAR-TELEGRAM EDITORIAL BOARD (10-25-09)

FORT WORTH LEAGUE OF NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATIONS (10-30-09)

WEST MEADOWBROOK NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION (8-08)

As the first urban gas drilling in the nation takes place in Fort Worth, residents from all over the city are questioning the wisdom of placing gas gathering pipelines in neighborhoods.

Pipelines of this nature have previously been run through rural areas with sparse populations. The dangerous gas flowing through these pipelines is odorless, high pressure, raw "wet" gas with the ability to corrode pipes in a few short years.  Pipeline explosions and accidents happen yearly. As the Barnett Shale play moves into the cities, tough decisions must be made between production interests and protection of residents.  If allowed to go through, Carter Avenue will be the first raw gas gathering pipeline to be drilled under multiple residential lots along several continuous streets.

Communities as far away as Pennsylvania and New York watch as events unfold.  They hope to learn and gain guidance from our experience here in Fort Worth as gas drilling activities approach their urban areas.

To learn more about the hazards associated with gas drilling, click here.


FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS:

1) "I thought our community lease took care of these issues"

The lease negotiated by the Greater Meadowbrook Minerals Leasing Task Force was with XTO, not Chesapeake.  XTO has agreed to respect our neighborhoods by not drilling within the residential areas.  Chesapeake is not bound by that lease agreement.

2) "Why should I be concerned about this - it's not on my street?"

Everyone in Meadowbrook (and all of Fort Worth) should be concerned about this Carter Avenue pipeline because it sets an historic precedent.  This is the first urban pipeline of its type to be run along a residential street.  Chesapeake owns at least two more large leases - one on Scenery Hill and one along Brentwood Stair.  Residents are concerned that future gas gathering lines and waste disposal pipelines could be run farther west along the Brentwood Stair corridor as far as Schilling and possibly further.

If it can be done on Carter Avenue, it can be done on your street!

3) "Aren't there already gas pipelines running in our streets?"

The residential gas lines that run to our homes are different from the proposed Carter Avenue pipeline. They are low pressure lines (approximately .5 PSI) and contain an odorant for easy leak detection. The Carter Avenue pipeline(s) will run at high-pressure  (approx 500-800 PSI) and without added odorant, meaning that you cannot easily smell a leak.  Also, the gas will be a highly corrosive, unprocessed "wet" gas coming straight from the wellhead.  There  have been several recent accidents where modern pipes have developed leaks in as little as 3 years.  The Chesapeake waivers that were signed by Carter Avenue homeowners indicate that multiple pipelines may be laid down, not just one.  How well will Carter residents to sleep at night knowing that potentially explosive pipeline lies in an easement just a few feet away from their beds?

4)
"I thought that City zoning ordinances prevent this type of development?"

In the state of Texas, the safety of gas pipelines are regulated by the Railroad Commission however they are still subject to City ordinances.  Some citizens assert that the City of Fort Worth is a "home rule" city which means we can make our own rules unless expressly forbidden by State law or the State Constitution and that the City has the power to determine where pipelines run within the city limits. City officials claim they must be reasonable in the process of refusing street crossing permits or they will be sued by owners/producers who are unable to get their gas to market.   Residents ask the question, "What is not reasonable about protecting the health and safety of Fort Worth citizens?".  There is another route for this pipeline - under I-30 and along the northside of the highway.

5)
"Why can't they run it along I-30?"

Recent meetings between the City and TXDOT reveal that Chesapeake never even filed for a permit to run this pipeline along the highway.  TXDOT says they have no objection to this pipeline.  Chesapeake has agreed to look again at a northern route along the north side of I-30 and to the west.  HB2572 allows for gas gathering pipelines to run ALONG public right-of-ways, with some considerations. It is entirely possible to run this pipeline along the northside of I-30 close to the already existing large Energy Transfer pipeline.

6)  "Why can't they run it north across I-30?"

The Trinity River Vision project is calling for the removal or rerouting of several pipelines along the Trinity in the area of the development  Only super deep pipelines will be allowed to remain. Chesapeake has already done one such deep bore across the river for the Hickman/Bayman wells.  Apparently they are not willing to do this again for the Thomas 1H well.  They would rather just run this pipeline underneath homes along city streets.  It's the cheapest and easiest way for them to go.   However, in the "community" meeting held on Oct 15, 2009, Chesapeake indicated they would be running the proposed Carter Avenue pipeline between 70' - 120' below the surface.  One has to ask then, if Chesapeake is going to do a super deep bore anyway, then why not run it to the north, underneath I-30 and Gateway Park to connect at the Bayman unit north of the park?

7) "I signed a mineral lease and don't feel right about fighting the pipeline"

Just because you signed a mineral lease, that does not give the gas company the authority to put your family at risk.  There usually are setbacks from 300' to 600' from public buildings.  Why should a home be subjected to a setback of only 10'?

Enter supporting content here